Pasta Salad
Overcook the pasta by a minute and dress it warm. Al dente pasta goes hard in the fridge, and cold pasta refuses to absorb anything.
- Prep
- 15 min
- Cook
- 12 min
- Resting
- 30 min
- Total
- 57 min
- Serves
- 6
- Revisions
- 1
Allergens
- Cereals containing gluten
- Milk
- Mustard
- Sulphites
Named from the ingredients as written, including those carried in from sub-recipes. This is not a guarantee — check the labels on what you actually buy, and note that a product’s recipe can change.
Ingredients
Serves
Pasta
Dressing
Salad
Method
Pasta
Boil the pasta in well-salted water for 1 minute LONGER than the packet says.
This is deliberate and it is the opposite of every other pasta instruction here. Starch retrogrades as it cools — the molecules recrystallise — so pasta that is perfectly al dente hot becomes unpleasantly hard straight from the fridge. A minute of overcooking compensates.
Drain it but do not rinse it. Rinsing washes off the starch the dressing needs to cling to.
Dressing
Whisk the oil, vinegar, mustard, garlic and salt together.
Pour half the dressing over the hot drained pasta and turn it through.
Dress it hot. Warm pasta absorbs the dressing; cold pasta lets it slide off and pool at the bottom of the bowl.
Leave to cool for 30 minutes, turning once or twice.
Salad
Fold in the tomatoes, pepper, cucumber, olives, onion and mozzarella with the rest of the dressing.
Add the basil last, torn rather than chopped, and taste for salt. It will need more than seems reasonable — cold food needs more seasoning than hot food to taste the same.
Nobody has rated this recipe yet.
Sign in to rate this recipe. One rating per person, and you can change it.
What to expect
- Taste
Sharp and savoury, and it needs to be — cold food registers salt and acid much less than hot food does, so a dressing that tastes slightly aggressive warm is about right cold.
- Aroma
Basil and vinegar. Mild.
- Texture
Soft pasta against crunchy pepper and cucumber, with the mozzarella soft and the olives chewy. Without the raw vegetables it is uniformly soft and dull.
- Sound
None.
- How the flavour moves
Acid and salt first, then the vegetables, then a long oily finish. Very little length, which is what a side dish wants.
- Serve it
Cool rather than cold. Straight from the fridge it tastes of very little.
- Goes with
Anything barbecued or cold. A buffet table. It is not a dish that stands alone.
Cook's notes
- Difficulty
Beginner, with one counterintuitive instruction.
- Cost
Low.
- Equipment
A large pan and a bowl.
- When to make it
Summer, and any time you need something that travels.
- Best season
Best in summer when the raw vegetables are worth eating.
- You know it is done when
The pasta should look glossy rather than dry, with no pool of dressing at the bottom of the bowl.
- And it feels like
Soft with a little resistance when cold. If it is hard, it was cooked al dente; if it is mushy, it went more than a minute over.
- Food safety
Cooked pasta and rice are the two foods where cooling matters most. Cool it within an hour, refrigerate promptly, and do not leave a dressed pasta salad standing at room temperature for more than two hours.
- Where it goes wrong
- Cooking it al dente, so it is hard when cold.
- Rinsing the pasta, which washes off the starch the dressing clings to.
- Dressing it cold, so the dressing pools at the bottom.
- Under-seasoning, because cold food needs more salt and acid than hot food.
- Adding the herbs early, where they blacken.
- Penne, which lets the dressing run through it.
- If it does go wrong
Hard: it was al dente; nothing fixes it now. Dry the next day: the pasta absorbed the dressing — add more oil and vinegar. Bland: salt and vinegar, in that order. Sitting in a puddle: it was dressed cold, and rinsing made it worse.
- Making it ahead
A day ahead, holding back a third of the dressing and the herbs until serving.
- Keeping it
Two days in the fridge. It absorbs dressing overnight and will want another splash of oil and vinegar.
- Reheating
No.
- Freezing
No.
- Leftovers
Eaten cold, with more dressing and more herbs.
- Scaling it
Doubles cleanly.
- Substitutions
Any short shape with texture to hold dressing — fusilli, farfalle, radiatori. Penne is a poor choice cold, because the dressing runs straight through the tubes.
- Dietary swaps
Contains gluten, milk from the mozzarella, and mustard and sulphites from the dressing. Vegan without the cheese, and gluten free with gluten-free pasta — though gluten-free pasta firms up considerably more in the fridge, so give it two extra minutes rather than one.
- Shopping for it
Nothing unusual.
- Keeping the cost down
Cheap already. The mozzarella is the only thing worth removing to save money.
- Sustainability
Almost entirely plant-based, and one of the lowest-impact things here. Dried pasta has a very low footprint and a long shelf life, and the vegetables are whatever is cheap and in season — this is a dish that adapts to what needs using up rather than dictating a shopping list, which is worth more than any single substitution. Left undressed, cooked pasta is also one of the most-wasted foods in British kitchens, and a salad is the standard answer to a pan of it.
- Nutrition
Mostly carbohydrate with a decent amount of raw vegetable.
- Worth it?
One extra minute in the pan and dressing it hot. Both feel wrong and both are right.
Where it comes from
- Origin
The United States, mid-twentieth century.
- Also called
None; insalata di pasta is the nearest Italian term and describes something rather different.
- Said out loud
Straightforward.
- What the name means
Descriptive.
- History
Cold pasta dishes exist in southern Italy but are a minor form and are usually dressed simply with oil, tomato and herbs. The pasta salad of buffets and delis is American, emerging in the mid-twentieth century alongside the rise of commercial mayonnaise and bottled dressings, and it reached Britain through supermarkets and party catering rather than through Italian restaurants.
- Why it matters
A buffet and packed-lunch fixture, and one of the dishes people are most often disappointed by without knowing why.
- When it is eaten
Barbecues, buffets, picnics, packed lunches.
- The traditional way
None.
- How it changed
Mayonnaise-based versions dominated in the United States; oil-and-vinegar versions are more common in Britain.
- Regional variations
American versions frequently use mayonnaise or a bottled Italian dressing. This one is a vinaigrette.
- How this version differs
The deliberate overcooking and the hot dressing are both stated as steps with the reason attached, because they are the two things that make the difference and neither is obvious.
- Sources and credit
None.
Cacio e Pepe
Spaghetti Carbonara
Air Fryer Halloumi
Braised White Beans with Sage
Creamy Tomato Pasta
Garlic Bread
Italian
Pasta
Side dishes
Vegetarian
30 minutes